Smart-E-Grid
Back to knowledgeEnergy knowledge

Market liberalisation and unbundling: why you choose your own supplier

3 min read

From integrated monopolies to competitive markets

For much of the 20th century, vertically integrated utilities dominated the European electricity sector: companies that owned production, grid and customer relationship at the same time. In Belgium this was not a classic state-owned company: Electrabel and the intercommunals were largely private or mixed. Prices and investments were therefore largely determined administratively, not driven by the market.

From the mid-1990s, successive EU energy packages forced Member States to take four major steps: open up production and supply to competition, unbundle monopoly networks from the competitive activities, guarantee non-discriminatory third-party access to transmission and distribution, and work towards one internal energy market. Directive 96/92/EC started with accounting unbundling. Directive 2003/54/EC enabled fully free choice of supplier. Directive 2009/72/EC made ownership unbundling of the TSO mandatory. The ultimate goal was efficiency, innovation, cross-border trade and freedom of choice for you as a consumer, while the networks themselves remained regulated natural monopolies.

Unbundling in practice

Production is competitive today, with market prices, PPAs and, where applicable, capacity mechanisms. Wholesale takes place via exchanges and OTC. Supply to end customers runs via customer contracts under a licensing regime. Transmission, on the other hand, remains a natural monopoly, operated by an independent transmission system operator at regulated tariffs. Distribution is also a natural monopoly, managed by regional distribution system operators, also at regulated tariffs.

Legal and functional unbundling concretely means that the grid operator may not favour its own production or supply branch over competitors, even though they used to be part of the same company. Independent regulators set the grid tariffs, or at least approve them, and supervise fair access rules for all market parties.

The Belgian institutional map

The Belgian Electricity Act of 29 April 1999 transposed the European frameworks. Elia has been the transmission system operator since 2002, responsible for the high-voltage grid and the system balance. Elia is ownership unbundled: CREG certified this on 6 December 2012. The retail market opened regionally: Flanders on 1 July 2003, Brussels and Wallonia on 1 January 2007. Distribution is carried out by regional grid operators: Fluvius in Flanders, Sibelga in Brussels, and ORES and RESA, among others, in Wallonia. CREG is the federal regulator. VREG, Brugel and CWaPE are the regional regulators for Flanders, Brussels and Wallonia respectively. The Belgian wholesale exchange was called Belpex until 2015; since then EPEX SPOT, alongside other European exchanges, has been the central market coupling interface for wholesale.

Grid tariffs, connection rules and the retail market design that you see can therefore differ per region, even though wholesale and transmission balancing are framed nationally and at European level.

Competition is incomplete by design

Pure, textbook competition is rare in capital-intensive energy systems. Regulators therefore continuously monitor market concentration, wholesale margins and entry barriers for new players. Networks remain monopolies by definition; production and retail can still be relatively concentrated among a limited number of large players. Policy instruments such as transparency obligations, market monitoring, capacity mechanisms and consumer protection therefore stand alongside pure market prices.

Relevance for SEG and for you as a customer

Unbundling explains why a VPP operator or supplier such as SEG can have access to the grid and to the markets without owning a cable itself, and why TSO reserve products and exchange trading are separate commercial interfaces, distinct from the grid connection processes with your local distribution system operator. It is precisely this separation that makes it possible for an independent player such as Smart-E-Grid to connect your battery to wholesale markets, without having to build any infrastructure itself.

Free advice call

Ready to manage your energy more smartly?

Leave your details and a Smart-E-Grid expert will contact you to schedule a no-obligation appointment.

  • Reply within 1 working day
  • Personal advice tailored to your installation
  • Completely free and no obligation

Request a no-obligation conversation

Get in touch Request a quote